A common surprise for merchants reviewing their abandoned checkouts: the shopper appears to have ticked "Email me with news and offers", yet the checkout's buyer_accepts_marketing field is false, and recovery tools that require consent skip the cart. This isn't a bug in your store: it follows from how Shopify records consent.
What Shopify's documentation says
Shopify's Help Center page on collecting customer contact information states that a customer's consent is captured at checkout when they select the marketing checkbox and proceed, by selecting Pay now on one-page checkout, or Continue to shipping on three-page checkout.
Since one-page checkout became Shopify's default in 2023, most stores run the single-page layout. Combine the two facts and the implication follows directly: on a one-page checkout, consent is recorded at Pay now, and an abandoned checkout is, by definition, one where the shopper never reached that point. So an abandoned cart from a new shopper will usually carry no recorded consent, even if the box was visibly ticked in the browser.
What we observed in testing
In our own tests on a development store (July 2026), the checkouts/create and checkouts/update webhooks for a fresh email address consistently arrived with buyer_accepts_marketing: false and no customer object, regardless of the checkbox state on screen, until the purchase was completed. We can't speak for every store configuration, but the behavior matched the documentation quoted above.
Why this matters for cart recovery
- Shopify's own abandoned checkout automation is, by default, only sent to customers subscribed to email marketing, which is one reason merchants often see few automatic recovery emails go out. (More on what the built-in email does and doesn't do in this article.)
- Any recovery app that strictly requires recorded consent will skip most abandoned carts from first-time shoppers, for the same reason.
- Returning customers who subscribed earlier (for example, during a previous completed purchase) do carry consent, so their abandoned carts can be emailed under a consent-required policy.
Options merchants have
There's no single right answer: the appropriate choice depends on where your shoppers are and how you weigh deliverability, regulation, and recovery volume:
- Send only to recorded consent. The most conservative policy; expect it to cover mostly returning subscribers.
- Send to all abandoners with a clear unsubscribe. A widespread industry practice in opt-out jurisdictions; rules differ by region (for example, several EU countries require prior consent for marketing email), so review the requirements that apply to your customers. This isn't legal advice.
- Use channels with their own opt-in. Web push permission is granted in the browser, separately from email consent.
Related reading: when Shopify actually creates an abandoned checkout.